Mindfulness is a quality of attention: noticing what is happening now, on purpose and without judging it. Meditation is a set of seated practices, and mindfulness meditation is the one that trains that quality, so they overlap but are not the same. Researchers still define mindfulness inconsistently, so study results don't always compare.
Mindfulness vs meditation: what is the difference?
Maybe a friend told you to 'be more mindful', and an app told you to meditate. You wonder if they mean the same thing, and which one you should do.
The short answer: mindfulness is a quality of attention, and meditation is a practice you set time aside for [1]. Mindfulness meditation is where the two meet, a seated practice that trains mindful attention [2].
You can be mindful while washing up, without meditating at all. You can also meditate in ways that have little to do with mindfulness, such as silently repeating a word or wishing others well [3] [4].
Below you'll find how researchers define each, a side-by-side table and a short seated exercise to try both. New to the whole idea? Start with what meditation is.
If you would like to try the meditation side for yourself, a guided session takes the guesswork out of those first minutes. Miracle of Mind is a free 7-minute guided meditation of breath and attention, designed by Sadhguru, that can send a daily reminder. It comes in 15 languages, with no ads and no subscription.
How to try both in 7 minutes
The quickest way to feel the difference is to try both, one after the other. Spend about 4 minutes in meditation, then 3 minutes bringing the same attention to a drink or a snack. That kind of attention to food also underpins mindful eating for weight loss.
- Sit comfortably. Use a chair or sofa with your feet flat, or sit cross-legged on a cushion. Keep your back upright but relaxed, with your hands resting in your lap.
- Gently close your eyes. If that feels uneasy, lower your gaze to a spot on the floor about a metre ahead.
- Rest your attention on the breath. Feel the air at the nose, or the rise and fall of your belly. Don't change it, just notice it.
- Come back when your mind wanders. Note where it went ('planning', 'worrying') and return to the breath without blame. Do this for about 4 minutes; this is the meditation part.
- Open your eyes and take a drink or a snack. Stay seated. Sip tea or water, or eat a few bites of fruit, slowly.
- Bring the same attention to it. Notice the warmth of the cup, the taste and the swallow. When your mind drifts, come back to these sensations; this is everyday mindfulness.
- Compare the two. Ask yourself which felt easier and which felt calmer. There is no right answer, only a clue about where to start.
The first part trained attention in a quiet setting, and the second used it in an ordinary moment. For the seated part, our free meditation timer ends with a soft bell, so you don't need to watch the clock.
Mindfulness, meditation and mindfulness meditation compared
In one line: mindfulness is the quality, meditation is the practice, and mindfulness meditation is the practice that trains that quality. The table sets the three side by side.
| Term | What it is | How you do it | Example | What research measures |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mindfulness | A quality of attention: noticing the present on purpose, without judging it [2] | Give full attention to whatever you are doing, at any time of day | Tasting each bite of lunch instead of eating while scrolling | Mostly questionnaires asking people how mindful they feel, which rely on self-report [6] |
| Meditation | A family of practices you set time aside for, usually sitting still [3] | Sit and train the mind with a focus such as the breath, a word or a feeling of kindness | Silently repeating a word, or wishing yourself and others well [4] | Changes in anxiety, depression or attention after weeks of practice [7] [8] |
| Mindfulness meditation | A meditation style that trains mindful attention, mixing focused attention and open awareness [9] | Sit, rest attention on the breath, and return each time the mind wanders | A short daily breath practice, or an 8-week course such as MBSR [2] | Mostly 8-week group courses; some trials test short app practices [7] [10] |
So when you read 'mindfulness' in a headline, check which row it means. A course, an app exercise and a questionnaire are very different things [5].
How do researchers define mindfulness and meditation?
Researchers define mindfulness as a way of paying attention, and meditation as the practices that train the mind. The best-known definitions come from a handful of papers.
Jon Kabat-Zinn, who developed Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR), describes mindfulness as 'paying attention on purpose, in the present moment, and nonjudgmentally' [2]. He taught it in a secular form in medical settings [2].
In 2004, a group of researchers proposed a two-part definition [1]. The first part is steering attention to keep it on what is happening now. The second is meeting that experience with curiosity, openness and acceptance.
Both parts count. Sharp attention with a harsh, critical attitude would not fit the definition [1].
For meditation, an influential 2008 review sorted practices into two broad styles [9]. Focused attention means holding attention on one object, such as the breath, and returning when it wanders. Open monitoring means noticing whatever arises, without reacting to it.
A 2015 review suggested mindfulness meditation works through three linked processes: attention control, emotion regulation and self-awareness [11]. Its authors noted that many of the studies behind it were small.
Other styles train different things. A review of 22 trials suggests kindness-based meditation can ease self-reported depression and raise self-compassion. Study quality was low to moderate [4].
What does everyday mindfulness look like?
Everyday mindfulness means giving full attention to an ordinary task while you do it. No cushion or set time is needed, so it fits into a busy day.
- Eating: take the first three bites of a meal slowly. Notice the colour, smell, texture and taste before you swallow.
- Washing up: feel the warmth of the water, the weight of each plate and the sound of the tap. When you start planning dinner, come back to your hands.
- Making tea or coffee: watch the water pour and the steam rise. Wait for the first sip before you reach for your phone.
- Brushing your teeth: feel the brush on each tooth and the taste of the paste, instead of running through the day ahead.
- Listening: in your next conversation, hear the other person's sentence to the end before you plan your reply.
- Waiting: in a queue or at a red light, feel your hands or feet and notice three sounds around you.
Mindful eating has the most research of these. A review of 68 publications suggests mindfulness approaches may help with binge eating and emotional eating, though not clearly with weight loss [12].
For the other examples we found no good trials, so treat them as ways to practise rather than tested methods.
Formal and informal practice: how the two work together
Mindfulness teachers often split training into two kinds. Formal practice is time set aside to sit and meditate. Informal practice is bringing the same attention into daily tasks.
One study hints that each kind may do a different job. In 205 medical students on a 5-week course, gains in mindfulness scores were linked to formal practice [13].
Gains in mental health and stress were linked to the quality of informal practice instead [13]. The study had no control group, so it shows links, not proof.
A practical way to combine them is to pair one short sit with one daily moment. Here is a simple first week to try:
| Days | Seated meditation | Everyday mindfulness |
|---|---|---|
| Days 1 to 2 | 3 minutes on the breath, soon after waking | The first three sips of your morning drink |
| Days 3 to 4 | 5 minutes, at the same time and place | Add brushing your teeth |
| Days 5 to 7 | 5 to 7 minutes | One conversation where you listen to the end |
Keep both short and at the same time each day. If you miss a day, start again the next morning; in a 2010 habit study of 96 volunteers, one missed day did not undo progress [14].
What has research found about mindfulness meditation?
Most of the evidence comes from mindfulness meditation courses, not from everyday mindfulness on its own. The researched benefits of meditation are real but modest.
A 2014 review of 47 trials with 3,515 people found small improvements in anxiety, depression and pain after mindfulness meditation programmes [7]. It found no evidence that meditation beat active treatments such as drugs or exercise [7].
A 2021 review of 136 trials in 11,605 adults found mindfulness programmes reduced anxiety, depression and distress compared with no programme [15]. They were not shown to beat other active wellbeing practices [15].
Attention changes a little too. A review of 87 studies found small but reliable gains in attention with meditation and mindfulness [8].
Is the mindful attention itself what helps? An early trial in college students hints so: becoming more mindful partly explained drops in stress and rumination [16]. The trial was small and used a waitlist comparison.
Sleep is another area with trials. A 2019 review of 18 trials with 1,654 people suggests mindfulness meditation improves sleep quality more than sleep education [17]. It was not clearly better than proven treatments such as talking therapy for insomnia (CBT-I) [17].
More practice is not always better. A review of 203 trials suggests longer programmes raised self-reported mindfulness but did not bring bigger drops in depression, anxiety or stress [18].
Short sessions can count. In a small trial of 71 novices, four 5-minute practices did as well as four 20-minute ones over two weeks [19].
What we don't know yet is how everyday mindfulness compares with sitting practice. We found no trial testing the two head to head, or comparing mindfulness meditation with mantra or kindness styles on the same measures.
Free toolNever meditated before? Try a 2-minute first meditationFree, in your browser, with a calm voice guiding youOpenWhy do people mix up mindfulness and meditation?
People mix them up because the two words so often appear together, as in 'mindfulness meditation'. Research itself adds to the confusion.
Fifteen researchers writing together warned in 2018 that 'mindfulness' is defined inconsistently across studies [5]. They also said many trials are small, and that media coverage often overstates the benefits [5].
Another expert review notes that meditation studies cannot be fully blinded and often rely on self-report [6]. So a result from an 8-week course doesn't automatically carry over to a 5-minute habit.
Mindfulness or meditation: which should you choose?
You don't have to choose: a short seated meditation plus a few mindful moments in the day works well for many people. Here is how to decide where to start.
- Start with meditation if you want a set routine, your mind races, or you like building a skill step by step. Our guide on how to meditate walks you through it.
- Start with everyday mindfulness if you can't find a quiet slot yet. Pick one daily task, such as your morning tea, and give it full attention.
- Choose a guided meditation if sitting alone feels hard. A voice gives a busy mind something to come back to; see what guided meditation is.
- Choose short sessions if time is the problem. A 5-minute meditation is a realistic daily start.
Whatever you pick, keep it small and daily. The attention you train while sitting is the same attention you bring to the washing up. If you are also weighing up movement, read how meditation and yoga differ.
When it feels hard: common problems and what to do
Most beginners run into at least one of these. None of them means mindfulness or meditation isn't for you.
- 'My mind won't stop.' That's normal. In a study of 2,250 adults, minds wandered in about 47% of moments sampled during daily life [20]. Noticing and coming back is the practice.
- 'I forget to be mindful during the day.' Tie it to one task you already do, such as your first drink of the day. One mindful moment a day is enough to begin.
- 'Meditation feels like another chore.' Shorten it to 3 to 5 minutes. In a small trial, 5-minute practices worked as well as 20-minute ones for novices [19].
- 'I get sleepy when I sit.' Sit up straighter, open your eyes a little, or practise earlier in the day.
- 'I'm not sure I'm doing it right.' If you noticed your mind had wandered and came back, you did it right. A guided recording can take the guesswork out.
- 'I use mindfulness to push bad feelings away.' The research definition asks for openness and acceptance, not control [1]. Try naming the feeling ('worry is here') and letting it stay while you return to the breath.
- 'Everyday mindfulness alone isn't doing much.' Add a short seated session to train the attention first. The daily moments then have a skill to draw on.
- 'Strong feelings come up.' Open your eyes, feel your feet on the floor and breathe normally. A review of 83 studies found about 8% of participants reported a negative effect, most often anxiety or low mood [21].
Is mindfulness meditation safe?
For most people, yes: the US National Institutes of Health calls meditation generally low risk [22]. A small share of people do have unpleasant effects, so stop if distress keeps building.
If you live with a mental health condition, talk to your doctor or therapist before starting a new practice. Keep following any treatment you have been given.
If you ever feel unsafe or in crisis, contact your local emergency services or find a free helpline at findahelpline.com.
What to try next
Once you know the difference, regular practice is what counts. Pick one of these and try it today.
- Learn the basics: read what meditation is, then follow the step-by-step guide to meditating.
- Calm a busy mind: if thoughts keep looping, try meditation for overthinking.
- Feel the body: a guided body scan moves attention slowly from your feet to your head.
- Time a silent session: use the free meditation timer with a soft bell at the end.
What the evidence can't tell us yet
- Definitions of mindfulness still vary between studies, so findings labelled 'mindfulness' don't always compare cleanly [5].
- Most trials tested structured courses, often 8 weeks long, not everyday mindfulness on its own [7].
- Mindfulness is mostly measured with self-report questionnaires, and meditation studies can't be fully blinded [6].
- Mindfulness programmes were not shown to work better than other active wellbeing practices [15].
- The formal versus informal practice finding comes from one study without a control group [13].
Why this matters for a 7-minute practice
A 7-minute guided practice of breath and attention belongs to the focused-attention style researchers describe [9]. Repeating it daily is one practical way to train the attention side of mindfulness. The trials cited here tested other formats, such as 8-week courses [7], so similar effects can't be assumed.
Frequently asked questions
Is mindfulness the same as meditation?
No. Mindfulness is a quality of attention you can bring to any moment, while meditation is a practice you set time aside for [1]. Mindfulness meditation is where the two overlap.
Is mindfulness a type of meditation?
Mindfulness itself is a quality, not a type. Mindfulness meditation is one type of meditation, and it trains that quality [9]. Other types use a word, or a feeling such as kindness, as the focus [4].
Can you practise mindfulness without meditating?
Yes. Kabat-Zinn's definition, paying attention on purpose and nonjudgmentally, can apply to eating, washing up or listening [2]. Many people find a short daily meditation makes it easier to remember during the day.
Which is better for anxiety, mindfulness or meditation?
Most anxiety evidence comes from mindfulness meditation courses, which gave small improvements in a review of 47 trials [7]. There is little research on everyday mindfulness alone for anxiety. If anxiety is severe or lasting, talk to a health professional.
How long should you practise mindfulness each day?
There is no agreed amount. A small trial found four 5-minute practices worked as well as 20-minute ones over two weeks [19]. A few minutes a day is a realistic start.
Is mindfulness meditation religious?
It has roots in contemplative traditions, but the version used in hospitals and research is taught in a secular form [2]. You can practise it without signing up to any belief system.
What is the difference between mindfulness and mindfulness meditation?
Mindfulness is the quality of attention itself. Mindfulness meditation is a seated practice that trains it, usually by resting on the breath and returning when the mind wanders [9].
Research and references
22 studies
- Bishop et al., 2004Consensus paper
Defines mindfulness as attention kept on present experience, met with curiosity, openness and acceptance.
Mindfulness: A proposed operational definition. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice.
- Kabat-Zinn, 2003Review
Mindfulness means paying attention on purpose, in the present, nonjudgmentally; taught in a secular form in medicine.
Mindfulness-based interventions in context: Past, present, and future. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice.
- Mayo Clinic Staff, current pageUniversity page
Meditation: A simple, fast way to reduce stress. Mayo Clinic.
- Galante et al., 2014Meta-analysis
Effect of kindness-based meditation on health and well-being: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology.
- Van Dam et al., 2018Review
Mindfulness is defined inconsistently, many studies are small, and media often overstate benefits.
Mind the Hype: A Critical Evaluation and Prescriptive Agenda for Research on Mindfulness and Meditation. Perspectives on Psychological Science.
- Davidson et al., 2015Review
Conceptual and methodological issues in research on mindfulness and meditation. American Psychologist (American Psychological Association).
- Goyal et al., 2014Meta-analysis
Across 47 trials (3,515 people), mindfulness meditation programmes gave small improvements in anxiety, depression and pain.
Meditation Programs for Psychological Stress and Well-being: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. JAMA Internal Medicine.
- Sumantry & Stewart, 2021Meta-analysis
Meditation, Mindfulness, and Attention: a Meta-analysis. Mindfulness.
- Lutz et al., 2008Review
Sorts meditation into focused-attention and open-monitoring styles with different attention effects.
Attention regulation and monitoring in meditation. Trends in Cognitive Sciences.
- Gál et al., 2021Meta-analysis
The efficacy of mindfulness meditation apps in enhancing users' well-being and mental health related outcomes: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Journal of Affective Disorders.
The neuroscience of mindfulness meditation. Nature Reviews Neuroscience.
- Warren et al., 2017Review
A structured literature review on the role of mindfulness, mindful eating and intuitive eating in changing eating behaviours: effectiveness and associated potential mechanisms. Nutrition Research Reviews (Cambridge University Press).
- Kakoschke N, Hassed C, Chambers R, Lee K, 2021Cohort study
In 205 medical students, mindfulness gains were linked to formal practice and wellbeing gains to informal practice; no control group.
The importance of formal versus informal mindfulness practice for enhancing psychological wellbeing and study engagement in a medical student cohort with a 5-week mindfulness-based lifestyle program. PLOS ONE.
- Lally et al., 2010Landmark study
How are habits formed: Modelling habit formation in the real world. European Journal of Social Psychology.
- Galante J et al., 2021Meta-analysis
Across 136 trials (11,605 adults), mindfulness programmes reduced anxiety and depression versus no programme, not versus other active practices.
Mindfulness-based programmes for mental health promotion in adults in nonclinical settings: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. PLOS Medicine.
Cultivating mindfulness: effects on well-being. Journal of Clinical Psychology (Wiley).
- Rusch et al., 2019Meta-analysis
The effect of mindfulness meditation on sleep quality: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.
- Strohmaier, 2020Meta-analysis
The relationship between doses of mindfulness-based programs and depression, anxiety, stress, and mindfulness: a dose-response meta-regression of randomized controlled trials. Mindfulness.
Effects of length of mindfulness practice on mindfulness, depression, anxiety and stress: a randomized controlled experiment. Mindfulness.
- Killingsworth & Gilbert, 2010Landmark study
A Wandering Mind Is an Unhappy Mind. Science.
- Farias M et al., 2020Systematic review
Adverse events in meditation practices and meditation-based therapies: a systematic review. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica.
- NCCIH (NIH), 2022Government page
Meditation and Mindfulness: Effectiveness and Safety. National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health.
This article is for general information and is not medical advice. If you are struggling, talk to a doctor or a qualified mental health professional. In a crisis, contact your local emergency number.